The Right Coast

Editor: Thomas A. Smith
University of San Diego
School of Law

Sunday, January 6, 2019

Can red state and blue state America coexist? - Washington Times

What if we arrived at a point where a solid majority of Californians truly wanted independence (and perhaps states like Washington and Oregon sought to join them)? Should they have the moral and constitutional right to do so? Would the other states ever impose military control over Californians to keep them in the Union?

The standard response is this issue was settled during the Civil War. Really? What the Civil War proved was that the North had more military might than the South — so it was able to impose its will over the rebel states. Imagine that it were the South in 1860 that held the political and military advantage to impose its will over the North, and moved to legalize the evil of slavery everywhere. Would the North have been morally wrong to secede?


If the South would have kicked our butts it would have been.

| Permalink


The Holy Constitution doesn't prohibit secession therefore secession is constitutional.

Posted by: dearieme | Jan 6, 2019 2:19:25 PM

OUR constitution is not 'Holy' it is just an almost perfect document for allowing a people to thrive and prosper, subject to amendments from time to time by its own rules. It is truly a non religious document, too bad you folks in the UK don't have anything like it.

Posted by: Stu Buchalter | Jan 7, 2019 6:02:34 AM