Monday, May 10, 2010

Tom Smith

General Kagan is "humbled" by her nomination.  That's a fine thing to say and people often say it on these occasions, but I wonder what it means exactly.  You say, the Chargers humbled the Redskins, say, meaning they put them in their place, but that's not what Kagan means, I don't think.  She means perhaps that she doesn't really deserve the honor, that she is not worthy?  In which case she means, I am so humble that I am saying I don't really deserve this?  Yet then people always go on to accept the honor.  I can't think of a case in which a high honor was offered to somebody and then they turned it down because they really didn't deserve it.  Obama had the perfect opportunity to do this with the recent Nobel Peace Prize (still embarrassing to contemplate) but alas he was merely humbled, not humble.  Or maybe it means, the largeness of the this office or honor makes me realize how small I really am.  Well, that's good, though I am a little bit opposed to so much puffing up of office, which after all is just an entirely artificial and finally political creation.  Let's remember our republican roots and all that.  One can say "I am humbled" by the office or whatever.  But if you said "You have humbled me" by the nomination or whatever, that would not sound right.  You honor me and yet I am humbled.  It has a kind of medieval even primatological feel to it, a ritual self-humiliation before one's benefactor, like getting on your knees before you are knighted.  Unfortunately I am too objectively humble ever to have to say I have been humbled, but if I ever am so humbled I at least hope it is an occasion for only the falsest of humilities.  The really bad thing is to have something to be genuinely humble about, as many of us know only too well.

| Permalink

TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Humbled
Tom Smith


George C. Scott declined to accept the Oscar for Best Actor for playing Patton, because he didn't think actors should be competing on such bases. It's not exactly the same as saying that he didn't deserve the honor, but it's sort of analogous.

Posted by: Tung Yin | May 10, 2010 3:04:27 PM

thank you for your post!

Posted by: p90x | May 17, 2010 11:02:28 PM

Birkentstock has over 200 years' history, is famous as its healthy and confort shoes.Nowadays, it is popular all over the world.
Everyone need to have a pair of Birkenstock shoes, especial the Birkenstock sandals,Birkenstock gizeh.Buy birkenstocks on, we are the largest and best online shop of Birkenstock.

Posted by: Birkenstock | May 27, 2010 8:13:13 PM