Right Coasters

Tip Jar

Change is Good

Tip Jar

Notable Posts

The Old Right Coast

Blog powered by TypePad
Member since 09/2005

« Economics One: More Monetary Policy Uncertainty | Main | Move Over Godzilla – Yale Researchers Name Reptile After President: ‘Obamadon’ »

December 14, 2012

Comments

I find both the original article and Lewis' take on it baffling. The WaPo article was a typical condescending liberal tale of small-town working-class Americans as helpless victims leading pathetic, degraded lives because of a lack of government programs, or something like that. Lewis' take was its conservative mirror image, a condescending tale of small-town working-class Americans as helpless victims leading pathetic, degraded lives because of a lack of traditional values, or something like that.

But the story as I read it was an inspiring tale of a young girl who saw the moral failings of those around her, imagined better things for herself, and appeared destined to work her way to achieving them. Assuming that she makes it through her EMT training, she'll no doubt get a good job, work hard at it, make a good living, eventually start a healthy family with an equally serious-minded person, and raise children who will have fine role models on which to pattern themselves.

Lewis' column is a sobering reminder that urban sophisticates tend to look down on the working class irrespective of their politics. The truth is that there have been dissipated people, dissipated families and even dissipated communities since time immemorial, and modern Americans have as good an opportunity to escape their surrounding dissipation as anyone in history. But when it comes to combating human vice, no top-down social ordering, whether liberal and government-driven or conservative and religion-driven, will ever substitute for individual human good sense and initiative.

The comments to this entry are closed.